Thursday, February 26, 2009

Similar Tactics to Power

My first reaction to the film was that it was a really sad situation, yet it is amazing the people are still holding strong and fighting back to the oppression by continuing their education. Looking back on it, you can really see the influences that fascist groups have over human psychology. The Taliban seem to use fascist tactics that have been used throughout the past to gain support at the same time as instilling a sense of fear and power. They have been trying to be the new totalitarian form of government through forcing people to conform to their radical views and have taken rash and quick momentary actions, such as throwing acid in girls faces and creating mass chaos. Although they seem to be a shady, unidentifiable group with no single leader, they have definitely used similar tactics as the nascent Nazi group when they rose to power. The Nazis were originally seen as a hoodlum gang, rather than a form of government. They gained support because Germany was suffering from the bad economy due to the aftermath of the war. They were able to steadily gain support through propaganda which convinced much of the youth. By taking control over the newspapers and other forms of communication, they were able to spread their ideas, scapegoating Jews, and creating xenophobia. These were all major contributing factors in their rise of support. Also, studies have shown that when a group does something that would normally be seen as unjust, people are much more likely to follow along because no one else is acting out. (group behavior) By creating a single ideal and mindset that many people conformed to, the Nazi party was able to take control of Germany. The Taliban too have been using similar tactics to gain support. They are primarily using fear to force people to conform to their leadership and their fundamentalist ideals. Their control over many parts of the middle east has greatly taken a toll on these countries economy and more importantly, their future generations. Hopefully the Taliban will be stopped and the millions of innocent people who are living in fear can get the education and the peace that they deserve.

6 comments:

  1. I think that this is great op-ed. You clearly have an opinion on the situation with the Taliban. What I thought was really interesting was how you weaved your opinion in with the evidence rather than just stating the evidence and then stating your opinion. It allows the reader some freedom to interpret what you are saying.

    You make several interesting points about the use of fear in society and about the idea of a mob mentality, and the only suggestion I have is that you could choose only one of these points and explore it more in depth. But this is not too big of a deal since it does not seem convoluted.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is obvious that this is an opinion piece from the very beginning. However, you manage to give your opinion, compare the Taliban to the Nazis, and state your evidence in a way that allows the reader to decide for themselves whether or not they agree with you. Instead of forcing your opinion (and what often happens is that someone is either persuasive or annoying), you present what you think in a way that is very admirable.

    My only suggestion would be to clarify the main point of connection between the Taliban and the Nazis that you are trying to make, because you talk about a lot of different stuff but seem to pick only one thing that links them. Overall, great job!

    -Sarah

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like your point that there was a known leader of the Nazis whom we knew by name, and how there is not a particular name that we see as the leader of the Taliban.

    I slightly disagree with your point about the Taliban using fear to gain support like the Nazis because, even though the Nazis used scare tactics, they did it at a time when they already had a large contingency of support. This is not consistent with the path of the Taliban because the Taliban do not have widespread support and yet they are already resorting to force and terror.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Right from the beginning, you form an opinion on the situation in Afghanistan, which I think is crucial to your op-ed. You present your view of the Taliban by comparing what they are doing to what the Nazis were doing. And while you say that the Nazis were slowly gaining momentum within the German people, you do not say the same of the Taliban. This is important because it shows that the people of Afghanistan will rise against their fascist rulers.
    Overall, a great opinionated op-ed.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is a wonderful op-ed. By adding emotion to your op-ed, we see details more clearly and it is easier for us to imagine how terrible life is in Afghanistan or how it was during the Nazi regime. However, I disagree with your comparison of the Nazi and the Taliban. The Taliban do not appeal as much to the masses, as did the Nazi party. They do however use similar tactics to get what they want.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I thought you did a great job on this op-ed. You told us your opinion in the beginning and that greatly improved your argument. I do disagree, however, with your comparison of the Nazis and Taliban. The Nazis were able to gain popularity in Germany through propaganda, not entirely through force, unlike the Taliban. Despite this, you still managed to write a very convincing op-ed

    ReplyDelete