Thursday, February 26, 2009

Parallels Between the Taliban and the Nazis

We study the fascist dictators of the early 20th century in a very simple-minded way. When we read about them in our World History book it truly makes them along with all of their ideas seem like: history. In our country, and specifically where we live, we see no trace of these ideas. But, the truth is that these ideas are still present in the modern world. The Taliban in Afghanistan are a modern example of a fascist group. By living in the United States and learning so much about the destruction that these reigns of dictators caused, it is clear to us that these ideas are not only morally wrong, but also unproductive. In the U.S. we are lucky to be able to practice a number of freedoms. We have a very powerful, stable, and democratic government. It would be nearly impossible for a fascist group to turn Americans off of the democratic government and on to them. In countries such as Afghanistan, it is the polar opposite. For many people, the Taliban seems very attractive. The government is unstable and distrusting. The Taliban provides a stable set of laws and an alternative to the unorganized and unproductive government. Sound familiar? In early twentieth century Germany, the economic troubles combined with the unstable government made the Nazi movement look promising. Both groups started and gained followers in the same manner. Many of their ideas are also very similar. They both value the traditional lifestyle of woman in the home (demonstrated by the story of the girls getting acid thrown in their faces when attempting to attend school) and violence and fear to gain followers. The Taliban have not gone as far as the Nazis, trying to limit the world to one race, but who's to say that eventually they won't. When we look back and learn about the enormous amount of terror that the Nazi party bestowed upon the world, we have to remember that history has a way of repeating itself. Let's not forget that at its early stages the Nazi party was simply regarded as an overthrowing of the communist government.  To paraphrase a character in Cabaret: They will overthrow the communists and then we will take over. Who's we? Germany.

8 comments:

  1. I like the way you start out by giving the reader something to connect to, then follow that up by connecting it to the situations in Afghanistan and Nazi Germany. Very nice use of transitions.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Like Kevin, I think that you connected the situations in Pakistan and in Nazi Germany very well. Another thing that I thought was very interesting was how your article imparts a sense of duty to do something on the reader without actually stating this anywhere in the article.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think your Op-ed is very well written and written in a way that we reminds us how greatful we should be that we are not being controlled by an inhumane dictator. (like germany was)
    Now since the majority of people do have an education, I don't think that we wuld let ourselves fall to the hands of a leader like Hitler or the Taliban. I think education plays an important role. If the people in Afghanistan (women) were to have an education, they would be able to realize that they are being completely controlled and be able to stop the Taliban. Since they don't have an education, they dont know what rights they could have.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I enjoyed the way your article wove in three different countries and their governments together. The point that you made of history repeating itself and that Americans need a wake-up call was very well put. The article clearly shows your point of view, while informing us of the history and present day at the same time.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You did a very good job of balancing facts with your opinions, which is just what an op-ed should do. The connections between Germany and Afghanistan are extremely well-done. This is a great piece of opinionated writing.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Rebecca,
    I really like your post, and i love the way you asked questions, its very engaging. As you said, "Living in the United States and learning so much about the destruction that these reigns of dictators caused, it is clear to us that these ideas are not only morally wrong, but also unproductive" you said dictators which is what immediately thought of when i heard fascism. However, I could not pin point the main leader of the Taliban, having one person in charge. So, for soley that reason I said the Taliban isn't a fascism regime. But very good Rebecca!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I like the way you introduced your piece. It gave me something to relate to while reading the rest of it. I also think that you presented great evidence and were able to incorporate America into the mix of countries in your argument. Good job.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I don't really know you or Mrs. P but this helped me out on my homework so good job bro.

    ReplyDelete